From Caramel to Raspberry Swirl, we bake 12 scrumptious brownie flavors here at Fairytale. Classic flavors, nutty flavors, adventurous flavors… a little something for everyone!
Now, we know the question has been burning at you forever: “Which brownie is most like me? Which brownie faithfully encompasses the deepest nuances of my personality?”
Wonder no longer! We’ve figured it all out so you can finally rest easy knowing which brownie you are based on your zodiac sign.
Bold. Confident. Energetic. This is the core of an Aries’s personality—and an accurate description of a strong, flavorful Espresso Nib brownie!
Aries are known for their passion and honesty. With enthusiasm and endless optimism, they like to be first in everything—and they’re determined enough to make it happen. Sounds like the warm, caffeine-enhanced flavor of espresso, doesn’t it?
All that energy and (admittedly, sometimes abrasive) arrogance can make an Aries come off as turbulent and unpredictable. Just like the crunchy cocoa nibs sprinkled on an Espresso Nib brownie, these rough spots might turn some people away. But those who can accept Aries for all they are know that this sign is full of passion, warmth, and loyalty for those they love most.
True to its element as an Earth sign, Taurus values tradition and stability. They’re practical, well-grounded, and one of the most reliable signs of the zodiac. It’s fitting that they gravitate toward a tried-and-true brownie flavor like Chocolate Chip.
That’s not to say Taurus are boring. Rather, they’re devoted and steadfast in their affections. Those born under Taurus know what they love, and they’ll stand their ground to prove it. They know they love chocolate, so that’s what they want in a brownie: more chocolate!
Love is a powerful motivator for Taurus. They’re deeply in touch with their sensual side, and they appreciate love and beauty in all its forms. And love is an extra indulgence of rich, decadent Belgian chocolate baked into each Chocolate Chip brownie.
Adventurous and always quick to adapt to change, those born under Gemini are motivated by endless curiosity and excitement about the world. They’re a warm, excitable, fun-loving sign—just like a warm, flavorful burst of buttery, crunchy toffee.
Contrary to what people think, Geminis aren’t two-faced in a dishonest sense. They’re just so expressive and quick-witted that they can bounce between ideas or emotions before everyone else can catch up.
It’s fairer to call them versatile or adaptable—just like the versatile flavor of a Toffee Crunch brownie. Sometimes you just bite brownie, sometimes you get a small corner of toffee, and sometimes you get a full toffee experience. And variety is the spice of life that the ever-changing Geminis love most!
Sweet, comforting, and reassuring, Cancers tend to be nurturers who are loyal and empathetic to those they love most. It’s a perfect match to the creamy, smooth flavor of a Cream Cheese brownie!
Because of their gentle nature, Cancers often play the role of peacemaker. Just like their brownie’s harmonic swirl of cream cheese and chocolate, this sign values harmony and balance. They’re quick to avoid conflict and will search for a solution that leaves everyone satisfied.
That said, at the end of the day, don’t assume Cancers will be a pushover. Those born under Cancer can be incredibly tenacious when their emotions take over. Cream Cheese may be subtle compared to some flashier brownies, but it’s steadfast and bursting with warm, enveloping flavor!
No brownie fits the fiery Leo sign better than Cinnamon Cocoa. Self-confident and compelling, Leos have a charismatic nature that makes them difficult to ignore—just like the irresistible allure of cinnamon.
Like the other fire signs of the zodiac, Leos are bursting with passion and warmth. Leos are so in love with life that others can’t help but be drawn into their aura. They’re dynamic. They’re creative. They’re the star of the show!
As natural-born leaders, Leos have an uncanny ability to unite those around them. It’s not too different than how the cinnamon, pecans, and chocolate combine their distinct flavors into a perfectly balanced Cinnamon Cocoa brownie.
Virgos are all about precision and organization. They strive for perfection, and that means taking a conservative, practical approach to life. There’s beauty and power in simplicity. Matching them to a classic Walnut brownie just makes sense!
Because of their keen attention to detail and their careful, methodical mindset, Virgos are often seen as the “control freaks” of the zodiac. They want nothing left to chance, and they won’t settle for anything less than perfect.
Walnut is a dependable, traditional brownie flavor that still requires careful attention to detail. You can’t have too many walnuts, or too few—it needs to be just right! Virgo’s practical side might even appreciate how walnuts on a brownie add a pinch of protein to their snack.
Ever notice the perfect symmetry of a pecan? Or the perfect balance between soft and crunchy in a Pecan brownie?
Cooperative and diplomatic, Libras are all about balance. They appreciate the best of both worlds, and they firmly believe in gestalt—that the balanced, organized whole is more valuable than its individual parts.
That said, Libras can be quite indecisive! When faced with multiple options, fair-minded Libras can see the value in all sides and struggle to settle on which one is best. They’d appreciate a flavor like Pecan, which is a healthy blend of all worlds. Flavorful but not overwhelming. A sensible blend of fudgy and crunchy. Not wildly exotic, but also far from plain. Something just right!
Caramel and Scorpio—what do they have in common? They’re both strong, passionate, and will stick to you like glue!
On the surface, Scorpios often seem calm, cool, and collected. But if you’re familiar with Scorpios, appearances are often misleading! Just like a Caramel brownie contains a hidden layer of rich, powerful caramel at the center, Scorpios at their heart are fiercely assertive, emotional, and passionate.
Scorpios are also notoriously stubborn. They’re not afraid to stand up for what they believe in. In friendships, that makes them incredibly loyal—a true friend and ally who will stay by your side through thick and thin.
True to a fire element, those born under Sagittarius burn bright and energize those around them. They have boundless passion for freedom and life—just like the bold, tangy burst of puree in a Raspberry Swirl brownie.
Sagittarius are also known as adventurers and world travelers, driven by their intense curiosity and free spirit. They’d definitely be the type to appreciate the strong, sweet-and-tart flavor combo of raspberry and rich dark chocolate. And did you know our raspberry puree is imported all the way from Italy?
Truthfully, all that idealistic enthusiasm combined with their honest nature can make a Sagittarius impatient and blunt—just as some might find a tart raspberry too sharp to enjoy. But when Sagittarius learn to properly express themselves, they’re an endless source of motivation and generosity for everyone in their circle.
Capricorns are all about tradition and discipline, making them the epitome of an Original brownie. Responsible and sometimes a bit serious, Capricorns are a sign of comfort and stability. They’re the ones you can count on when all else fails!
Capricorns don’t hold themselves to rules arbitrarily. They simply hold a lot of value in the experience that’s been gained and perfected over time. They learn from their past mistakes, and each failure makes them much stronger in the end.
That said, we think Capricorns would appreciate the 60+ years of tradition behind our cherished family brownie recipe.
Just as mint can be a subtle flavor, so too is Aquarius seen as the shy, quiet sign of the zodiac. Deep thinkers and problem solvers, Aquarius spend a lot of time in their own heads!
Unfortunately, people tend to misinterpret an Aquarius’s withdrawn personality as insensitive or standoffish. Cold, like peppermint. But that’s not necessarily true! This is just how Aquarius protects themselves against premature familiarity.
Just as an eccentric Aquarius will thrive in the right environment, mint can too. Think about it—mojitos, lamb with mint sauce, Mint Chocolate brownies. With the right blend and a healthy dose of creative freedom, mint (and by extension, an Aquarius) can provide warmth, energy, and innovative flavor!
Pisces are kind, selfless, and often considered the most tolerant of the signs. As a water sign, Pisces are often led by their hearts—that is to say, their compassion, empathy, and generosity.
That gentle, friendly disposition common to Pisces perfectly mirrors the delicate flavor and silky texture of a White Chocolate brownie! Smooth and creamy, high-quality white chocolate complements and highlights the flavors around it without being overwhelming.
Pisces are also known to have an artistic side, just as white chocolate is a beloved decoration in baking. Isn’t that icing drizzled over a brownie just gorgeous?
This is the second or third time I have received an assortment of Fairytale Brownies from my son for Mother’s Day. I love them. After removing what I knew would be my favorites I shared “just one each ” with two friends… and both commented that it was THE BEST brownie either has ever had..